The Comprehensive Guide to Probate, Trusts, Estate Planning, and Inheritance Litigation

Must an Estate Have a Lawyer in Federal Court?

The rules of each state vary in terms of whether the personal representative (also known as an executor) must have a lawyer in state court for purposes of probate administration.     Although federal courts will not handle probate administration matters, federal courts can hear a large variety of cases involving estates.  A common example is a wrongful death suit, where the estate sues the alleged tortfeasor in federal court.

Does an Estate Have to Have a Lawyer in Federal Court?

Yes, an estate must be represented by a lawyer to appear in federal court.

The recent case of Laibow v. Menashe, 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 3066 (D.N.J. Jan. 8, 2020) explains the operation and purpose of the rule.  In the Laibow case, Ms. Laibow was the executor of the estate of her husband, Maj. General Albert Stubblebine III.  She sued several medical institutions and medical institutions for negligence and other causes of action that she alleged led to his death.  Ms. Laibow appeared in federal court as the plaintiff / executor without an attorney.

In dismissing her complaint, the Federal District Court for the District of New Jersey reasoned as follows:

Although a non-lawyer is entitled to represent herself pro se, she may not appear pro se on behalf of another person or entity. Schneller v. Crozer Chester Med. Ctr., 276 F. App’x 169, 170 n.1 (3d Cir. 2008). That rule has particular application to an appearance on behalf of an entity that is not a natural person.

In Estate of Twardy v. Lakes of Larchmont Condo Ass’n, No. 15-6501, 2016 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 65322 at *1, 2016 WL 2901664 (D.N.J. May 18, 2016) (Hillman, J.), the estate’s executor filed a pro se complaint on behalf of the estate. Id. The case came before the court on plaintiffs in forma pauperis motion, but the court expanded its inquiry to consider whether the executor was entitled to prosecute the action in the first place. Id. at *2 (“[I]t is highly questionable whether an executor of an estate who is not an attorney may file suit on behalf of an estate.”).

Estate of Twardy collects some of the most pertinent case law. It cites, but does not explicitly adopt, the most liberal standard of pro se representation, which  is that an executor may represent the estate pro se, but only if she is the sole beneficiary and the estate has no creditors.

Even under the most liberal view, then, a pro se plaintiff purporting to represent a decedent’s estate must demonstrate that the estate has no other beneficiaries or creditors. The purpose of this rule is to ensure that the rights of the estate’s beneficiaries or creditors are adequately protected. See Murray v. City of Phila., 901 F.3d 169, 171 (3d Cir. 2018) (“Attorneys’ training, experience, and their ‘ethical responsibilities and obligations’ help ensure that a represented party’s interests are not squandered . . . . Only attorneys may be sued for legal malpractice; a represented party could not seek recourse against a non-attorney for even the most egregious conduct.” (citations omitted)).

All of that said, the Murray decision might be read to suggest in dictum that, if faced by the issue, it would adopt what I  have termed the “liberal view” that the sole beneficiary of an estate with no creditors may represent it in federal court. Murray cited with approval several cases that, if only by negative implication, acknowledge or adopt that view.

Ms. Laibow has not pled or otherwise established both that she is the sole beneficiary of the estate and  that there are no other creditors. Dr. Menashe’s motion to dismiss is therefore GRANTED. The dismissal is, however, without prejudice, because it is not futile to anticipate that this defect could be cured—if not by amendment of the complaint, then surely by retention of an attorney to represent the estate.

Find Your Florida Probate Star

Orange County (Orlando)

Philip W. Gunthert

Broward County (Ft. Lauderdale)

Natasha M. Dalton

Pinellas County (Clearwater)

Matthew Weidner

Sarasota County

Dawn Bates-Buchanan

Hillsborough County (Tampa)

R. Todd Burbine

Palm Beach County

Nicole Quattrocchi

Lee County (Ft. Myers)

Scott Kuhn

Marion County (Ocala)

Katina Pantazis

Pasco County (Port Richey)

Matthew Weidner

Collier County (Naples)

Gregory J. Nussbickel

St. Lucie County

Romaine Brown

Miami

Niuris Bezanilla

Volusia County (Daytona)

Heather Caeners

Martin County (Stuart)

Jon L. Martin

Duval County (Jacksonville)

Long H. Duong

Sumter County (The Villages)

Matthew Weidner

Polk County (Lakeland)

Lesly Vaillancourt

Manatee County

Brice Zoecklein

Seminole County (Sanford)

Matthew Weidner

Monroe County (Key West)

Matthew Weidner

Osceola County (South Orlando)

Matthew Weidner

Lake County (West Orlando)

Matthew Weidner

Charlotte County

Matthew Weidner

Find Your California Probate Star

Los Angeles County

Stewart J. Levin

San Diego

Merwyn J. Miller

San Bernardino County

Fred W. Edwards

Ventura County

Naomi Stal

San Mateo County

Sally Bergman

Stanislaus County (Modesto)

Thomas Bonte

Orange County

Priscilla Madrid

Santa Clara County

Nicholas P. Jellins

Find Your Texas Probate Star

San Antonio

Gilbert Vara, Jr.

Houston

Grace P. Shoemakers

Austin

Kyle Robbins

Dallas

Steven S. Boss

Grayson County

Jacob Pelley

Williamson County

Lorenza Cigarroa

Find Your New York Probate Star

Nassau County

Cyrus Shaw

Westchester County

Anthony Nigro

Brooklyn

Inna Fershteyn

Erie County

Ruth P. George

Queens

Rudolf Karvay

Suffolk County

Marc Weissman

Rockland County

Ari J. Zaltz

Find Your Ohio Probate Star

Hamilton County (Cincinnati)

Jennifer R. Harlow

Franklin County (Columbus)

Eric McLoughlin

Find Your Maryland Probate Star

Prince George's County

Ralph W. Powers, Jr.

Calvert County

Zach W. Worshtil